Whatever ball gives you the best scoring is your best ball.  If you gain an advantage in the fairway and don't lose any accuracy getting on the greens....

In your comments about the cover, don't know if you tried the 2013 ProV's, but mine seem to rival the non-urethane balls in durability.  But then again, I haven't challenged as many tree trunks or cart paths as I used to and I don't generate a great deal of backspin with wedges.

I tried both and the nxt tour is better for me too....my favorite ball out there

I agree with you guys, the NXT Tour and NXT Tour S are great!  I have a tendency to fade my drives, and these balls don't fade like the ProV1x's.  Great ball, and even better on our wallets!

I have just started back playing golf from 20 years off.  A lot has changed, no 2 irons any longer but the one thing that didn’t change was Titleist!  I purchased a dozen Pro V1x and a dozen NXT Tour balls.  Since I was just getting going again I really couldn’t tell the difference.  Since I have purchase another dozen of the NXT Tour S, I really seem to like those best right now.  The funny thing is I have 3 sleeves of DT Titleist that were 20 years old.  I figure they had lost their pep, but surprisingly I hit them just as far, but I gave them to my nephew.  I am going to just play and let which one I like the best be my ball.  I also purchased a set of AP2 irons, love them!  Thank you Titleist!!